Have you ever faced a situation where your boss becomes your student - and openly confronts your expertise? Here's how I navigated one of the most challenging moments in my training career.
At a leading tech company, just after the CEO finished introducing my training session and I took the stage, I noticed something that made my heart sink. While everyone else was attentively focused on my presentation, one person immediately returned to his seat and started browsing his phone and laptop. My stomach tightened as I realized it was none other than the CEO who had just introduced me!
The situation quickly escalated. The CEO began confronting me on several points during the session, creating an increasingly tense atmosphere. Though I managed to address each objection effectively, I could sense an underlying resistance that threatened to derail the entire day's training. The energy in the room was palpable - and not in a good way.
This wasn't my first experience teaching high-level executives. I've had various board chairs and CEOs attend my full-day sessions, some even bringing their executive assistants. Since publishing my book "The Art of Public Speaking," I've noticed an increasing trend of senior executives in my courses. These leaders typically showed exceptional engagement, with many even declining phone calls during sessions. But this adversarial classroom dynamic, initiated by the top executive? That was unprecedented.
What were my options? Turning to HR for help wasn't a feasible solution - after all, who would confront the CEO? Should I suggest he focus on his work elsewhere? Or should I simply proceed with delivering high-quality training, regardless of the circumstances?
When I shared this dilemma on Facebook, the suggestions poured in:
"Keep engaging him in discussion"
"Invite him to demonstrate"
"Praise and encourage him"
"Face the confrontation head-on with a challenging task!"
While these suggestions had merit, I knew I needed a more nuanced approach.
First, ignoring the situation wasn't an option. As the instructor, I own the responsibility for everyone's learning outcomes. The atmosphere had to improve - period.
However, direct confrontation carried too much risk. While some suggested immediately engaging the CEO or asking him to present, such approaches could backfire. My goal was to enhance the training effectiveness, not engage in a power struggle.
Instead, during the break, I strategically pulled the CEO aside. "Do you have any feedback on the previous session?" I asked, maintaining a professional yet open demeanor. To my amazement, he was effusive with praise! "You're incredibly skilled! Not just in teaching, but in how precisely you answer questions!" I kept my composure despite my internal relief.
Building on this opening, I asked about areas for improvement. He mentioned wanting more presentation practice opportunities for the team and helping them develop more structured communication - both topics already planned for later sessions.
Then came my calculated risk: "I need your help." I explained how his engagement significantly influenced others' participation and would appreciate his active involvement in the next exercise. "When the CEO fully engages, it elevates everyone's performance," I explained. He not only understood but enthusiastically agreed.
The transformation was immediate and dramatic. In the next exercise, the CEO not only participated - he excelled. But the real victory wasn't his performance; it was watching him close his laptop, put away his phone, and become fully immersed in the training. The entire room's energy shifted with his engagement.
By day's end, the CEO declared it "the best professional development course I've attended in recent years!" The HR director, beaming with satisfaction, immediately began discussing next year's training schedule.
Three Critical Lessons from This Experience:
1. Embrace full responsibility for your classroom, regardless of who's present. Don't just manage the room—own it!
2. Prioritize outcomes over methods. Adapt your approach to achieve the best results, even when facing unexpected challenges. Sometimes, indirect solutions yield the most powerful results.
3. Senior leadership presence fundamentally shapes group dynamics. Transform potential resistance into powerful advocacy through strategic engagement.
Postscript:
This experience taught me that excellence in training isn't just about delivering content - it's about masterfully managing complex dynamics, even when they take unexpected turns. Each challenging situation offers an opportunity to move closer to our ideal of perfect execution, one small step at a time. The key isn't avoiding difficult moments but learning to transform them into opportunities for breakthrough results.
No comments:
Post a Comment